Kim Sang Sik's 'Troop Split': A Plan With No Squad List, and Two Horizons 1,100 Kilometres Apart
Q: Vì sao đội tuyển Việt Nam và U23 Việt Nam tập huấn song song trong tháng 11/2026? A: VFF tổ chức hai đợt tập huấn song song trong cùng một khung lịch FIFA tháng 11/2026 nhằm chuẩn bị cho Asian Cup 2027 và vòng loại U23 châu Á 2028, với đội tuyển quốc gia đá giao hữu tại Ninh Bình và U23 Việt Nam dự VTV Cup tại Pleiku. Key facts: - VTV Cup tại Pleiku diễn ra từ ngày 10 đến ngày 14 tháng 11 năm 2026, gồm bốn đội: U23 Việt Nam, U23 Thái Lan, U23 Singapore và U23 Qatar. - Đội tuyển quốc gia Việt Nam đá giao hữu với Đài Bắc Trung Hoa và Kyrgyzstan tại Ninh Bình trong cùng khung lịch. - Đội tuyển quốc gia do huấn luyện viên Kim Sang Sik dẫn dắt; đội U23 do một huấn luyện viên khác phụ trách, theo cách VFF đã áp dụng ở các đợt tập huấn trước. - Giải thưởng cho đội vô địch VTV Cup là 100.000 đô la Mỹ; vé có ba mức giá 200.000, 300.000 và 400.000 đồng. - Mục tiêu chiến lược được VFF nêu rõ là Asian Cup 2027 và vòng loại U23 châu Á 2028; khung tuổi đủ điều kiện của đội U23 không được công bố. Source: Vietnam Football Federation communiqué, General Secretary Nguyen Van Phu press conference | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Q: Vì sao đội hình U23 Việt Nam có thể được công bố muộn hơn đội tuyển quốc gia? A: Các trận giao hữu cấp đội tuyển quốc gia 'A' thuộc lịch thi đấu quốc tế FIFA nên câu lạc bộ buộc phải nhả người, trong khi VTV Cup là giải mời cấp U23 không thuộc nhóm bắt buộc nhả người, khiến danh sách U23 phụ thuộc vào thiện chí của câu lạc bộ và dễ bị điều chỉnh. Q: Huấn luyện viên Kim Sang Sik có trực tiếp xem các trận U23 Việt Nam ở Pleiku không? A: Rất khó, do Ninh Bình và Pleiku cách nhau khoảng 1.100 km đường bộ và hai sự kiện chạy trên lịch trùng nhau, nên việc đánh giá cầu thủ U23 sẽ được chuyển tiếp qua ban huấn luyện U23. Q: Giá trị công nghiệp dài hạn của VTV Cup phụ thuộc vào yếu tố nào? A: Vào tính lặp lại — một giải mời tổ chức một lần đóng góp gần như bằng không cho chu kỳ 2028, trong khi một giải được đưa vào lịch thường niên tạo ra tài sản phát triển có lãi kép, theo chỉ số VangBong.vn Player Depth Index về mật độ cầu thủ trẻ được sử dụng thi đấu.
Pleiku and Ninh Binh are roughly 1,100 kilometres apart by road. In the same week of November, Vietnam's U23 team will play three matches in Gia Lai, while the senior national team plays friendlies in Ninh Binh. The single most important selector in Vietnamese football will not spend a minute in Pleiku.
People read the Vietnam Football Federation's communiqué and find a very soothing word: parallel preparation. Parallel means two straight lines that never meet. In geometry, that is a definition. In football, it is a problem.
I went back through the fifteen information points the VFF released, and the first thing I did was count what was not in them. No squad list. No player-allocation criteria. No name for the U23 head coach. No stated eligible birth cohort for the 2028 U23 Asian qualifiers. No figure for organisational cost. General Secretary Nguyen Van Phu says Kim is coordinating with colleagues to allocate players — present tense. The article describes a process in motion, not an outcome.
That is the most striking thing, and it is not an editorial accident. A federation announces fixtures, opponents, prize money, ticket prices, the identity of its coaching representation — yet withholds precisely the one part fans care about. This is risk-managed communications: publish the process, retain the substance. It is effective for institutional image control, and it renders every downstream analysis an analysis conducted in the dark.
The tournament runs from November 10 to November 14, 2026: four teams, six matches across three matchdays. The opponent order is U23 Thailand, U23 Singapore, U23 Qatar. Hard, easy, hard. The two heaviest fixtures sit at the two extremes — meaning the opener carries maximum pressure before the team has rhythm, and the closer carries maximum physical load after three matches in five days have ground down the legs. For a young squad, this is the most demanding configuration available, whether designed or merely a consequence of scheduling.
U23 Thailand is the identity fixture. Meeting Thailand on day one means the match that defines the tournament arrives before the team has taken shape. U23 Qatar is the West Asian physical and technical benchmark, the type of opponent Southeast Asian football routinely breaks against in the second half. U23 Singapore is the lowest-information fixture and the logical rotation match. Three different stress tests — and inviting a West Asian side to home soil is the correct instinct, because Vietnam's Asian Cup group-stage opponents will overwhelmingly come from West and Central Asia, not Southeast Asia.
But the crux is not the U23 tournament. It is that the two squads do not share the same level of legal obligation.
The senior friendlies against Chinese Taipei and Kyrgyzstan are 'A' internationals inside the FIFA international match calendar. There, clubs are obliged to release players. The VTV Cup in Pleiku is an invitational at U23 level — not covered by automatic mandatory release. Clubs can decline, delay, or release a player carrying a minor knock that has not healed.
In other words: the senior squad can be guaranteed by law. The U23 squad is guaranteed only by goodwill. In a window where the V.League is still running and several clubs still have late-season objectives, goodwill is the most perishable asset there is. The U23 list will almost certainly be published later, and revised more often. That is the operational signature of a non-mandatory release mechanism, not a sign of crisis.
This leads to a consequence I believe is under-weighted. If the U23 side plays a different system from the senior team, and if the U23 coach is a different person — as in previous training camps, to use the VFF's own phrasing — then the tournament produces players evaluated as individuals but never integrated as a collective. The pipeline leaks precisely at the handover point. A player who excels in Pleiku will be registered through reports and video, not through the direct eye of the man who actually picks the squad.

That is a real information-loss channel, and it has a specific address: the Pleiku-Ninh Binh distance. The two events run on overlapping dates. Nobody can be in both places.
Economically, this is a self-funding event at the margin. The champion's prize is USD 100,000. Tickets come in three tiers: 200,000, 300,000 and 400,000 VND. The top tier is around USD 16 — at or above the premium end of Vietnamese domestic football pricing. An organiser setting that price in Pleiku is betting on local demand, and the bet has a basis: Gia Lai is one of the most football-literate regions in the country. But it must be said plainly: if attendance underperforms, the tournament's intrinsic value erodes faster than its sporting value.
And there is an incentive misalignment here worth naming. With a USD 100,000 prize, the U23 coaching staff has a genuine incentive to select the strongest players currently available in order to win matches — not necessarily the cohort the 2028 U23 Asian qualifier objective requires. In youth football, prize money and player development do not always point the same way. A three-match, five-day tournament with a six-figure prize is a good environment for short-term results and a poor environment for patience.
Where could I be wrong?
Three places. First, V.League clubs may cooperate fully, and the non-mandatory release argument may be a theoretical worry with no practical consequence. In Vietnam, the VFF is also the regulator of the professional league, so the club-versus-country friction that is a European football speciality has little ground to grow in. That is a genuine structural advantage, and it could neutralise my entire concern. Second, the U23 side may in fact play a shared tactical framework with the senior team that the communiqué simply does not mention, with continuity existing at an invisible layer. Third, the missing squad list may simply reflect an allocation process that is not finished, rather than a deliberate communications strategy.
But even if all three hold, one question remains intact: if this tournament is a genuine development platform for the 2028 cycle, why is the eligible birth cohort absent from every line? For a programme aimed at the 2028 qualifiers, the age cohort is the parameter that defines the entire programme. Its absence is not a minor detail.

And there is one more variable on which the tournament's industrial value depends entirely: recurrence. A one-off invitational contributes close to nothing to the 2028 cycle. A tournament written into the annual calendar creates a compounding development asset — a platform, a data set, relationships with peer federations, and a date that clubs must factor into their season planning. The communiqué says nothing about this. The silence here costs more than any wording.
I have watched enough of these camps to know one thing: the order of publication always reveals more than the content of the publication.
If the two squad lists are released together, that is a coordinated plan. If they are released apart, or if the U23 list arrives late with a few names withdrawn for medical reasons, then what was called parallel preparation has quietly become prioritised preparation — and fans will read its true nature correctly without anyone explaining it. People do not need a statement to know which team is prioritised. They only need to count who is missing.
A championship never comes from the fixture list, but people need an excuse to hate the strong. Here there is no strong side to hate yet. There are only two horizons 1,100 kilometres apart, and one man who must choose which one to stand on.
