Trang chủDomestic FootballEuropean expert: V-League must build football culture from youth level

European expert: V-League must build football culture from youth level

V-League cần giáo dục văn hóa bóng đá từ tuyến trẻ, theo chuyên gia châu Âu trả lời Dân trí. Gốc rễ nằm ở đào tạo HLV, án phạt thiếu răn đe và chuẩn mực của đàn anh. Key facts: - Văn Hậu bị treo giò 4 trận sau pha vào bóng nguy hiểm với Doãn Ngọc Tân. - Tấn Sinh và Văn Sơn bị nêu tên vì cố tình kéo ngã Đình Bắc. - Chuyên gia nhấn mạnh kỹ thuật xoạc bóng và tôn trọng đối thủ từ cấp trẻ. - VFF và VPF cần án phạt mạnh hơn, nhất quán hơn. Nguồn: Dân trí | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Related Q&A: Q: Vì sao V-League khó hết bạo lực? A: Vì thói quen được hình thành từ tuyến trẻ và hệ thống HLV thiếu chứng chỉ. Q: Giải pháp dài hạn là gì? A: Đào tạo HLV có chứng chỉ và xây dựng quy tắc ứng xử từ học viện trẻ. Q: Án phạt hiện tại có hiệu quả không? A: Chuyên gia cho rằng nếu tái phạm vẫn diễn ra, án phạt chưa đủ sức răn đe.

On a rainy night in Hanoi, on a slippery pitch, Van Hau lunged into the ball with an uncontrolled challenge. Doan Ngoc Tan went down. The referee showed a card. Later, the disciplinary board issued a four-match ban. The story did not stop there. Within a short window early in the season, Tan Sinh and Van Son were singled out for deliberate fouls on Dinh Bac, a rising player. The public asked a hard question: why has Vietnamese football produced so much violence? A European expert, in an interview with Dan tri, offered a diagnosis different from the mainstream view. He argued that the V-League must build football culture from the youth level, rather than relying only on sanctions. He did not talk about talent or physicality. He talked about tackling technique, managing duels, and controlling emotions in decisive moments. In his view, Vietnamese players are not born aggressive. They are taught in a way that allows roughness to become a habit. I have followed Asian football for years, from the J-League to the K-League, then the V-League. Based on my experience watching matches, I partly agree with this view: the tackling culture of Vietnamese football, and Southeast Asian football in general, differs from European standards. But the deeper story is about how the entire system teaches young players to face pressure, pride, and opponents. The Incheon lesson taught me: rumors are wind, verification is the door. For Vietnamese football, the door that needs verification is not a contract, but the youth development system. When a young player learns, at fifteen, that intimidation can win matches, that instinct travels with him into the first team. The European expert pointed out something difficult to hear: many V-League players do not know how to tackle properly. They throw themselves into contact with feeling, attacking the man instead of the ball. A correct sliding tackle is a skill that must be coached from childhood, step by step. A licensed coach knows how to teach a child to control the leg, the fall, the distance. A coach who relies only on playing experience teaches by instinct, and the instinct of the old-school player is to intimidate, to charge in, to punish the opponent. Football cannot run on unlicensed coaches. A league that wants to rise at the continental level needs licensed coaches, a proper curriculum, and a system of continuous education. The problem is not a few dangerous tackles. The problem is that we are allowing a generation of players to learn defending the way it was done decades ago. The bigger concern is the top-down transmission of culture. Young players always look at their seniors. When an experienced defender makes a dangerous tackle and earns fear from opponents, the message sent to youth football is clear: violence works. If punishments are strong and consistent, the V-League will teach a generation that the line between intensity and danger is absolute. This is a circle: bad habits flow from the professional level down to the youth level, then that youth level produces players who bring those habits back to the professional level. The expert argued that professional football must educate culture from the youth level. Anyone can punish. But punishing the right person, at the right level, at the right time, is the art of governance. He also stressed that responsibility belongs to both VFF and VPF, because football culture cannot be built by a disciplinary committee alone. I have seen many suspension bans in Southeast Asia dismissed as warnings. But if dangerous incidents keep recurring after every punishment, the disciplinary system is failing in its preventive role. A ban is not only about punishing a mistake. It must deter other players from repeating it. If the sanction is too soft, it becomes a license to pay the price for violent play. I watched the Kim Min-jae deal collapse at the last moment, and I understand the cost of haste. Changing people cannot be rushed. A football nation that wants to change its violent habits cannot be rushed either. A short coaching course will not transform a coach who has spent thirty years on the pitch. A heavy ban will not transform a player raised on an old football mindset. But starting from the youth level, change is possible. Behind every transfer deal is a story that contracts never tell. Behind every violent challenge is the same truth: the story of a player who was taught the wrong way long before he stepped onto a professional pitch. However, we must also look at the blind spot in this framing. The youth education narrative is correct, but it can become a trap that delays current responsibility. When an adult player deliberately tries to take down an opponent, that is not about technique. That is intent. The case of Tan Sinh and Van Son both targeting Dinh Bac in a short period cannot be explained by poor tackling skill. It is a signal of intimidation, an old-school football tactic. If we label everything as an education gap, we unintentionally excuse deliberate behavior. The interview raised another issue. The expert's identity was not named. A European perspective brings objectivity, but it is also difficult to verify. His recommendations resemble what any modern football administrator would say: coach education, youth development, consistent discipline. If Dan tri keeps using the image of a European expert to elevate its argument, readers have the right to ask why there is no real name. I do not write to shock. I write so that the truth can settle. The truth here is that the V-League is paying the price for a football education system that has been neglected for too long. More bans will not change it. Longer suspensions will not change it. The only thing that can break the cycle of violence is a generation of well-trained coaches who understand child psychology, individual technique, and the boundary between intensity and dangerous behavior. The transfer market is like a chessboard: spectators see the move that has been made, insiders see the move that has not been made. For football culture, the unplayed move sits in youth academies, in coach licensing programs, in the codes of conduct written for ten-year-old players. The V-League can keep punishing, or it can start teaching. Are we brave enough to wait for a generation that is taught correctly from the start? The lesson from Incheon and the lesson from these suspension bans point to the same conclusion: without fundamental change, every new season is only a repeat of the old script. A dangerous tackle, a ban, a debate, then silence until the next round. To escape that loop, Vietnamese football must treat youth development as the foundation, coaches as the center of change, and sanctions as the final tool, not the first solution.
Cầu thủ liên quan