Trang chủDomestic FootballV-League Pitch Violence: When Referees Miss Cards, and No One Dares Blow the Whistle Backwards

V-League Pitch Violence: When Referees Miss Cards, and No One Dares Blow the Whistle Backwards

**Core answer (≤60 words):** Four violent incidents across three rounds of V-League 2026-2027 prompted VFF, VPF and the tournament organisers to meet the VFF Referees Committee on September 20, demanding correct rule enforcement. Referee Le Vu Linh showed only a yellow card to Huynh Tan Sinh for two cold-blooded fouls on Nguyen Dinh Bac, and no red card was given. **Key facts:** - September 20: Le Van Son elbowed Nguyen Dinh Bac; Huynh Tan Sinh fouled Dinh Bac twice, receiving only a yellow card. - Round 2, V-League 2026-2027: Doan Van Hau broke Doan Ngoc Tan's leg; Ezeqiuel Santos Da Silva stamped on Vo Huu Viet Hoang. - Duong Vu Lam, former VFF Vice President and former Head of the VFF Referees Committee, said referee Le Vu Linh missed a card. - VAR team members Vo Hoai Thuong and Nguyen Thanh Son face responsibility checks over whether they advised a red card. - Referee disciplinary rulings are not publicly announced; absence from the next rounds' referee list implies suspension. **Source attribution:** Dan Tri, interview published after the September 20 match between Dong Nai and Cong An Ha Noi | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A:** Q: Will Huynh Tan Sinh be banned retrospectively? A: Duong Vu Lam stated that if Tan Sinh is retrospectively banned, referee Le Vu Linh must be suspended in the same manner. Q: What happens if the VAR team did not advise a red card? A: Under Mr Lam's reasoning, the VAR referees Vo Hoai Thuong and Nguyen Thanh Son must also be disciplined for failing to advise a red card. Q: How can fans detect whether a referee has been punished? A: By checking the referee appointment list in the rounds immediately following; absence indicates likely discipline, per VangBong.vn Referee Appointment Index data.

Minute 63, Dong Nai stadium. The ball had rolled away long ago; behind it, only an elbow remained. Le Van Son, defender of Dong Nai FC, turned and threw his elbow towards Nguyen Dinh Bac, striker of Cong An Ha Noi FC. The ball was no longer there. Only people were. Dinh Bac fell, dust clinging to his shoulder. Referee Le Vu Linh's whistle sounded, and in the stands, the noise was not about a goal or a red card, but about a familiar question: this time, who will be punished, and who will be allowed to stay silent?

Less than an hour later, it was the turn of Huynh Tan Sinh, centre-back of Dong Nai FC itself. Not once, but twice. "Bo bong da nguoi" - the Vietnamese football phrase for a tackle that is no longer aimed at winning the ball, but at hurting a person. Tan Sinh tackled from behind, into Dinh Bac's leg, the first time. Then the second time. Referee Le Vu Linh showed a yellow card. Just one yellow card for two offences, for a deliberate act, for a cold-blooded foul that could not be more obvious.

That was September 20. The match between Dong Nai and Cong An Ha Noi. And within that brief window, Vietnamese football once again had the occasion to talk about something no one wants to mention in front of the cameras: violence on the pitch.

I watched this match back twice, not to find fault with an individual, but to find the moment when the match changed its character. There is a minute when a defender realises that his opponent will not be protected, and football ceases to be football. It becomes a bargain between fear and punishment - in which the reward for the reckless is often greater than the price they pay.

These two ugly incidents did not come out of nowhere. They came after two other tackles, only a round earlier. Centre-back Doan Van Hau of Cong An Ha Noi broke the leg of midfielder Doan Ngoc Tan of The Cong Viettel. Foreign player Ezeqiuel Santos Da Silva of Nam Dinh stamped on the stomach of Vo Huu Viet Hoang of SHB Da Nang. Both belonged to round 2 of V-League 2026-2027.

Four tackles. Three rounds. One league. If this were a fever, the temperature had reached a level the organisers could no longer ignore. And they did not ignore it.

Representatives of the tournament's Organising Committee, the Vietnam Professional Football Joint Stock Company (VPF) and the Vietnam Football Federation (VFF) met directly with the VFF Referees Committee. In that meeting, the demand was very clear: referees must apply the law correctly, uphold the discipline of the tournament, and prevent violent behaviour on the pitch.

It sounds simple. But the phrase "apply the law correctly" here is not merely a reminder about professional standards. It is a warning about consequences: do not allow missed fouls, missed cards. And that very "missing" happened in front of tens of thousands of spectators, in the Dong Nai versus Cong An Ha Noi match on September 20.

In the situation where Huynh Tan Sinh abandoned the ball to attack Dinh Bac, referee Le Vu Linh used only a yellow card. He did not show a red, even though Tan Sinh had fouled Dinh Bac twice. The question is not whether Mr Linh saw it - he saw it, because he blew his whistle and showed a card. The question lies elsewhere: why did that seeing lead to such a lenient decision?

Speaking to a Dan Tri journalist after the match, former VFF Vice President for Professional Affairs and former Head of the VFF Referees Committee Duong Vu Lam commented bluntly: "Referee Le Vu Linh missed a card, in relation to this situation. Huynh Tan Sinh's abandonment of the ball to attack the man was too blatant, yet no red card was given".

But the more important statement lies in the next paragraph. Mr Lam said: "If there is retrospective punishment, banning Tan Sinh for this foul, then referee Le Vu Linh must similarly be suspended. In addition, the responsibility of the VAR team must be clarified. If the VAR team, comprising Mr Vo Hoai Thuong and Mr Nguyen Thanh Son, advised the main referee but was overruled by the main referee, then the VAR team has fulfilled its duty. Conversely, if the VAR team did not advise main referee Le Vu Linh that a red card should be used for the aforementioned foul, the VAR referees must also be dealt with".

This is the most valuable sentence in the whole story, and I believe many people read it and skimmed past. Because it does not speak of a tackle. It speaks of a system.

In more than five decades of watching football, I have realised that people usually argue about players - the one who tackled, the one who was tackled, the one who deserves a ban - but they argue extremely little about the person blowing the whistle. And that is precisely the blind spot.

Imagine the retrospective punishment mechanism - the tool Vietnamese football uses to correct errors after the match. The Disciplinary Committee reviews the footage, sees an act of violence the referee missed, and bans the player. This approach seems reasonable: though late, justice arrives.

But that justice is only half. The player is banned. What about the referee? Disciplinary rulings for referees, by convention, are not widely published. No one knows whether Mr Linh was suspended. No one knows whether the VAR team performed its role correctly. No one knows whether the referee assessment process was influenced by any pressure.

Mr Duong Vu Lam revealed how to see through that curtain: "Usually, specific disciplinary rulings for referees are not widely published, but if you watch the referee list in the following rounds, you will know whether the referees involved have been suspended. If they are not appointed in the rounds immediately following the round just played, the likelihood is high that they are being disciplined".

This is a very clever observation, and also a very sad one. Because it shows that the transparency of Vietnamese professional football is fragmented. Fans can look up how many matches a player is banned for. But they cannot look up how long a referee is suspended. Collective memory remembers players. Collective memory forgets referees.

And when memory forgets, responsibility loosens.

I came to football through my ears. In 2026, I began working at local radio stations, and for many years I heard football over the airwaves rather than watching it on a screen. People told me about the match, and the way they told me revealed what was more memorable than the score. They remembered the tackles where "the referee stood right there and did not blow". They remembered the names of players who were tackled. And they almost never remembered the names of referees - unless that referee did something too wrong.

Silence is a kind of referee. It controls the match in ways the scoreboard cannot reflect. When a referee does not show a red card for a cold-blooded foul, he does not merely overlook a mistake. He is sending a message to all 22 players on the pitch: "this zone is a safe zone".

And in football, a safe zone for the violent is precisely a danger zone for the fair.

I witnessed this at the 2026 World Cup, when, aged 61, I sat in the press room in Moscow. France versus Argentina in the quarter-finals. Kylian Mbappe, 19 years old, dribbled through 11 presses and scored twice in a 4-3 win. He ran so fast that I forgot the score, focusing only on feet turning into poetry on the grass. But behind that beauty lies a truth few mention: for Mbappe to run like that, the referee had to protect him from the opponent's destructive tackles. Without protection, there is no beauty. Football is not naturally beautiful. It is kept beautiful.

Youth is not only speed, but the way one chooses to charge forward. And the way they choose to charge forward depends greatly on whether they believe they will be protected.

Back to V-League. At 69, I have learned that the world still runs faster than me, but memory always stands still. And what I remember most after each season is not the beautiful goals, but the seasons in which pitch violence was pushed back. Because those are the seasons in which Vietnamese football truly matured.

V-League once had very bad periods on this issue. In the early 2000s, when the league had just turned professional, pitch violence was a predicted part of many matches. Referees were few, experience was thin, and VAR did not exist. People watched football by remembering the names of those who specialised in tackling people, as they remembered characters in a play.

Then V-League matured. There was VAR. There was a Disciplinary Committee. There was retrospective punishment. There were clearer procedures. Fans began to believe violence would be punished. And that very belief helped Vietnamese football rise.

But belief is fragile. Four tackles in three rounds were enough to crack it.

There is one thing I consider central to this story, and few want to say it plainly: the nature of pitch violence does not lie with the players, but with the gap between the rule and the enforcement of the rule. Any player will try to exploit that gap. The fair player tries too, when he feels unprotected. The violent player tries even more, because he knows the price is cheap.

In football, the price of an act of violence is not measured by the pain it causes, but by the probability of it being punished. And that probability - precisely that probability - is the product of many layers of decision: the main referee, the VAR team, the Disciplinary Committee, the Referees Committee, the tournament organisers.

When all those layers run smoothly, violence is eliminated at the root. When one layer is blocked, the whole system is blocked with it.

In the Dong Nai versus Cong An Ha Noi match on September 20, which layer was blocked?

In my view, there were two.

The first is the main referee layer. Referee Le Vu Linh saw the tackle. He blew his whistle. He showed a yellow. But he did not show a red. In a foul where the keyword "cold-blooded tackle twice" is enough to say everything, a yellow is a lenient decision. So lenient that Mr Duong Vu Lam himself, who once sat in the head of the referees' chair, had to speak up.

The second is the VAR layer. This is the more subtle, harder-to-assess layer. VAR is not an automatic red-card machine. It is a process of people - people sitting in a closed room, reviewing footage, and making recommendations to the main referee. In the case of the aforementioned match, the VAR team comprised Mr Vo Hoai Thuong and Mr Nguyen Thanh Son.

The question Mr Duong Vu Lam posed is very precise: did the VAR team intervene or not? If it intervened and was overruled by the main referee, the responsibility belongs to the main referee. If it did not intervene, the responsibility belongs to VAR. This is a binary question, and it could be answered if the operating procedure were transparent enough.

The problem is: the operating procedure is not transparent enough.

We do not have a mechanism to publicly announce VAR recommendations after each match. We do not have a mechanism to publicly announce disciplinary measures for referees. We have a system of dual punishment - players banned publicly, referees suspended quietly - and this very asymmetry creates a lingering sense of injustice in the hearts of spectators.

Fans do not need technical details. They need to know one thing only: was the wrongdoer punished or not. And if they are not given an answer, they will build their own. Usually, that answer is more pessimistic than reality. And usually, it is also right.

This is where I must say something I believe is true, even if it may displease some people in the profession.

For many years, Vietnamese football has focused too much on educating players. Clubs hold sessions on "fair play". Young players are taught not to destroy opponents. But there has been almost no national campaign to make referee handling transparent. Referees are told to "apply the law correctly", yet they themselves do not have an environment transparent enough to apply the law fully.

I am not saying referees make no mistakes. I am saying the system was not designed so that referees can correct their own mistakes.

Look at how European football operates. There, major leagues publicly release exchanges between the main referee and VAR in certain cases. They publish sanctions for referees. They hold regular briefings on referee appointment procedures. Of course, they also make mistakes. But the gap between error and silence is far smaller there than with us.

In V-League, referee sanctions are a grey zone. And that grey zone, though invisible, is shaping players' behaviour on the pitch.

There is a story I want to tell. In 2026, when the pandemic silenced every stand in Chengdu, I - then 63 years old - carried out a project called "Green Balcony". I video-called 50 veteran supporters of Sichuan Jiuniu, a club that once had 43,000 spectators per match and then had only the drone of cicadas. I recorded 300 minutes of their memories of afternoons waiting for the ball to roll. I helped them speak out, turning memory into collective diary pages.

What I learned from that project is: fans remember what they feel, not what they are told. They remember a bad match because it hurt them. They remember a good match because it made them happy. And they remember a violent match, because it made them believe football was lying to them.

Empty seats still sing, because memory is also a kind of supporter. And sometimes, disappointment is too. It does not go anywhere. It quietly sits down in another seat, and waits for a day to be spoken.

Back to Duong Vu Lam. He said something I consider very important: if Tan Sinh is retrospectively punished, then Le Vu Linh must also be suspended. In other words, there cannot be two sets of standards - one for players, one for referees.

This is a very simple yet very profound principle. In a just system, every operating component must bear proportionate responsibility. If a player is banned for a foul, the referee who overlooked it must also be assessed. Not for revenge, but for the integrity of the system.

A system that only punishes players and never punishes itself is a system that cannot improve. It can only repeat.

I think this is the point many people in Vietnamese football overlook. When pitch violence occurs, the reaction is usually: "Suspend this player! Heavily fine that club!". But if referees are not seriously assessed, then no matter how many players you suspend, violence will be reborn. Because the root cause of pitch violence is, after all, not the aggressive nature of players. The root cause is uncertainty about punishment.

When a player knows he will be banned for three matches if he breaks an opponent's leg, he will think. When he knows the probability is 50%, he will bargain with luck. And when he knows the probability is only 20%, he will not even consider considering it.

Probability is everything.

And that probability is determined by referees, maintained by VAR, reinforced by the Disciplinary Committee, and shaped by the Referees Committee. If any of those layers fails to fulfil its duty, that probability collapses. And when that probability collapses, the pitch becomes a place with no law.

The pitch never betrays anyone, it is just that people often forget it also knows how to embrace. It embraces the fair, and it also embraces the violent. It does not discriminate. It only reflects what people sow into it.

There is another aspect I want to address here: Vietnamese football is at a sensitive moment in its development cycle. V-League 2026-2027 has only passed a few rounds, yet has witnessed a chain of events that has caused public concern. If the organisers do not handle it decisively, these events will shape the whole season. Fans will sit down at every match with a question in their heads: "Who will be tackled today?". That is a terrible question with which to begin a football match.

Football is played to answer better questions. Who will score? Who will assist? Who will shine? When those questions are replaced by questions about violence, football is losing its soul.

And I, at 69, with more than half a century in the profession, do not want to write articles about pitch violence one more time. But I also know that if I do not write, the problem will not disappear. It will only stay silent, waiting for the next incident.

There is one thing I always tell myself whenever I sit down to write: I write slowly, because football is not in a hurry - it only waits for those patient enough to understand. And that patience, in this case, requires me to look at what people usually do not want to look at: the structure of silence.

Because silence is not the absence of a voice. It is the presence of another voice, stronger, but hidden. That voice says: "Do not deal with referees, because if we do, we will have to admit that our system has a problem".

This is precisely the counter-intuitive point I want to emphasise in this article. When we talk about pitch violence, we usually ask: "Why do players tackle people?". That is an easy question, and its answer is easy too. But the harder question is: "Why does the system allow players to tackle people?". The answer to this question requires us to look at the structure of the handling procedure, the transparency of sanctions, the responsibility of VAR, and how the VFF Referees Committee assesses its own members.

In the specific case of the Dong Nai versus Cong An Ha Noi match, we have an opportunity to answer this hard question. If the VAR team intervened and was overruled, we will know the problem lies with the main referee. If the VAR team did not intervene, we will know the problem lies with the VAR procedure. In either case, we learn something about the system.

The problem is: will we be allowed to know?

By convention, we will not. We will only see the referee list in the following rounds, and infer. As Mr Duong Vu Lam suggested: "If they are not appointed in the rounds immediately following the round just played, the likelihood is high that they are being disciplined".

This is a clever way of reasoning, but it is also a sign of weakness in Vietnamese football's communication. A truly professional football nation would not need to infer. It would have a public page on referee sanctions. It would have a periodic report on referee performance. It would have a channel of dialogue with fans about controversial decisions.

We do not yet have those things. And that is part of the problem.

Someone might object: "Publicising referee sanctions will reduce referees' authority on the pitch". This is a familiar argument, and it has a grain of truth. Referees need authority to control a match. If that authority is eroded by publicity, referee quality may suffer.

But I consider this a false trade-off. A referee's authority does not come from mystery. It comes from consistency. A respected referee is respected not because people know nothing about him, but because people believe he will make the right decision. And that belief can only be built through transparency, not through silence.

If fans know that a referee has been suspended for a serious mistake, they will trust the system more. They will know that a self-correcting mechanism is operating. Conversely, when they only see players punished and not referees, they will believe the system protects insiders. And that belief, once lost, is hard to regain.

Supporters do not die, they merely move to an empty seat to watch the pitch longer. They do not need a packed stadium. They need a fair stadium. And fairness, in football, begins with the smallest things: from a red card shown at the right moment, from a sanction announced in the right way, from a referee assessed at the right level.

I do not know what the final outcome of this story will be. Perhaps the VAR team will be dealt with. Perhaps referee Le Vu Linh will be suspended for a few rounds. Perhaps Huynh Tan Sinh will be banned for the cold-blooded foul. Perhaps Le Van Son will also be dealt with for the elbow.

But I know one thing: if the handling remains the old handling - transparent with players, silent with referees - the problem will not be solved. It will only be postponed. And in football, postponement is never a strategy. It is only a way to prolong the pain.

A championship is an embrace, but the most beautiful embrace is when the pitch holds the losers. And that can only happen if the losers believe they lost fairly. In the Dong Nai versus Cong An Ha Noi match, some players lost. But the real question is: will they believe that loss was fair?

I have no answer to that question. And perhaps no one does. But I know Vietnamese football needs to answer it - not with a press release, but with a truly transparent mechanism.

Because in football, as in life, the most important thing is not whether we make mistakes, but whether, after making them, we dare to look straight into the mirror.