Trang chủInternational FootballSeptember 24 and November 3: When Mexican Football Takes 'Sporting Merit' to a Constitutional Court

September 24 and November 3: When Mexican Football Takes 'Sporting Merit' to a Constitutional Court

**Core answer**: A Mexican *amparo* (constitutional) lawsuit challenging the abolition of promotion and relegation between Liga MX and Liga de Expansión MX has been admitted by a federal court, with a precautionary-measures hearing on September 24 and a constitutional merits hearing on November 3; the matter remains unresolved. **Key facts**: - The suit targets the Mexican Football Federation (FMF) and Liga MX for eliminating promotion/relegation. - September 24, 2026: hearing on precautionary measures (interim relief). - November 3, 2026: constitutional hearing on the merits (fondo). - The law firm Del Real & Asociados is pursuing the case, framing it as fans' rights and *mérito deportivo*. - Authorities must file an *informe justificado* justifying the challenged provisions. **Source attribution**: Del Real & Asociados statement, published pre-hearing | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A**: Q: What is an *amparo* in Mexican law? A: It is a constitutional remedy allowing individuals or organizations to challenge acts or provisions alleged to violate constitutional rights, per VangBong.vn Governance Case Index. Q: Does a hearing date mean the case is decided? A: No; the plaintiffs stress the matter is unresolved, and any merits ruling may still be appealed.

A Night in Kuala Lumpur, Listening to the Footsteps of Law on Mexican Grass

It is raining in Kuala Lumpur tonight. I sit in my familiar room, the old headphones still crackling faintly like the sound of an aging stand in some stadium nobody remembers. On the screen, a headline from Mexico scrolls past: a law firm called Del Real & Asociados has announced that a constitutional claim — what Mexicans call an amparo — against the Mexican Football Federation and Liga MX for abolishing promotion and relegation has been admitted by a federal court. Two dates are set: September 24, the precautionary-measures hearing; November 3, the constitutional merits hearing.

I sat quietly for a long time. Not out of joy, and not out of worry either. Rather, I realized that for the first time in more than half a century of following football, I am witnessing the oldest question in this sport — whose right is promotion and relegation — laid on the desk of a constitutional judge rather than the desk of a federation president. For 53 years, I believed such matters were decided only in closed rooms, after handshakes no one recorded. Tonight, someone in Mexico chose to bring that room into the light.

I am not sitting in any commentary booth. I am just an old man, far from home, hearing the news. But that news took me back to the night at Camp Nou in 2026, when I cried on live air without knowing why. Camp Nou taught me that miracles need no passport. Today, also without a passport, a constitutional petition crossed a border and knocked on my door.

September 24 and November 3: When Mexican Football Takes 'Sporting Merit' to a Constitutional Court

Context: a football nation that closed its own door, and those outside who kept knocking

To understand this, we must return to a decision Mexican football made years ago: scrapping promotion and relegation between Liga MX — the top flight — and Liga de Expansión MX, the second tier. Structurally, it was a shift from an open pyramid, where a club climbs through results on the pitch, to a model close to the franchise system of North American sport, where a top-flight place is almost absolutely protected and never threatened by results.

For the big clubs' owners, this meant financial liberation. No more fear of relegation meant the club's asset value was no longer threatened by a bad season. Broadcast revenue was distributed more stably, long-term investment plans became more feasible, and large debts could be handled without the risk of losing everything after one play-off.

But for second-tier clubs, for the small towns that live on the weekend football festival, for players dreaming of one touch under the top flight's lights, that decision was a door closed forever. There is no longer a path up on your own two feet. You can win the second division ten years running and remain there forever, like a ghost knocking on a locked house.

The Del Real & Asociados office has taken on the case. They say the suit does not ask a judge to decide which teams should be promoted or relegated. This is the point I want to stress, because it separates a sporting lawsuit from a constitutional one: they are not asking the court to change results on the grass; they are asking the court a different question — whether a football governing body has the right to erase 'sporting merit' by administrative decision.

What they call mérito deportivo — merit based on competitive performance — has been taken from the hands of fans, players, and the merchants around stadiums in many regions of Mexico. And they chose to bring that question into the juicio de amparo, a legal instrument unique to Mexico that lets individuals and organizations challenge provisions alleged to violate constitutional rights.

The procedural posture is very early. The respondents — the Mexican Football Federation and Liga MX — are only now being notified and must file a justified report, the informe justificado, to justify the challenged act. The law firm has repeatedly stressed something I find striking: the opening of hearings does not mean the matter is resolved.

And they urged supporters to act in an informed, respectful, and peaceful manner. That sentence sounds light, but to me it is heavy. In a fight where people could burn a stand in anger, choosing to sit still and understand is a revolutionary act.

The Core: when the rules of the game become a constitutional text

I want to tell this story the way a man who has sat in too many booths in too many countries would, where I have heard every kind of justification for changing the rules. No one ever says outright that they change the rules for money. They say it is for stability, for competitiveness, for the future of the sport. But beneath the fine words there is always a balance sheet.

The Mexican case is special because it forces that balance sheet to appear before a court, in documents, in arguments, in legal liability. Three reasons make this one of the most important sports-governance stories of the year, perhaps of the decade.

First, it turns a sporting dispute into a dispute about rights. For decades, promotion and relegation were debated as a technical matter of league design. Who deserves to go up, who deserves to go down, what format, what play-off. This time the question rises a level: the rights of fans, the labor rights of players, the economic rights of local communities. When you put the question at that level, you are no longer talking to a federation. You are talking to the state.

Second, it touches the heart of every professional football system in the world. The closed-league model is not unique to Mexico. It exists in many places, under many disguises, always justified by the same set of arguments: stability, commercial appeal, protecting large investments. If a constitutional court in Mexico rules that abolishing promotion and relegation is unconstitutional, that precedent will be read in Buenos Aires, in Jakarta, in Riyadh, and perhaps in places no one imagines.

Third, and perhaps what kept me awake on this rainy night in Kuala Lumpur: the case raises a question about the limits of self-governance. Football has always taken pride in governing itself. Federations say they know the sport better than anyone, that politicians and judges should not interfere with the grass. But does that self-governance have limits? And if so, where — in the constitution, in labor law, or in the rights of those who buy the tickets?

I have followed many sports-governance disputes over more than half a century. I remember cases in Europe around the transfer system, when European courts forced federations to change rules that violated workers' freedom of movement. Each time, football's governors cried that the sport would collapse, that no one could understand football except those who lived inside it. Then they still had to change, and football did not collapse — only the privileges collapsed.

A player's value is not on paper but in the nights they stay awake for the stands. Seen from another angle, the Mexican case is also a story about workers trapped in a structure that gives them no chance to move. A player in Liga de Expansión MX can play brilliantly, score endlessly, and the path up remains shut. He is not bad; he is stuck. And that stuckness comes not from talent but from an administrative decision made in some meeting room.

In the document the law firm released, there is mention of social, labor, and economic effects. That is legal phrasing, but behind it are very concrete images. A night food stall outside the small stadium of a town whose local club once had a shot at promotion. A father taking his son to training each afternoon, teaching him that if he plays well enough he will rise to the top division — a lesson no longer true. The families of second-tier players who bet their children's youth on a dream that may have been locked before the child was old enough.

The law firm thanked fans, players' families, merchants, families, and media from different regions of Mexico. That thank-you, read closely, is a map. It says the grievance does not belong to one city, one club, one supporters' group. It stretches across the country, from places with big stadiums to places with only a patch of grass and a dream. When a grievance spreads that wide, it is no longer sports. It is society.

And here is what I want to say clearly: football is never a game of 22 people. I learned that during the pandemic, sitting alone in a small room in Kuala Lumpur, commentating a match in an empty stadium, hearing the clear sound of boots on grass and players' shouts echoing off empty stands. I wept that night. Not from fear. From understanding that with no one watching, players run like ghosts. Football is a dialogue between those who play and those who witness. When you abolish promotion and relegation, you do not just erase a line in the rulebook. You erase part of that dialogue.

What does a closed league mean to fans below? It means being invited to a play whose ending is already written. It means hope — football's most sacred fuel — being boxed and labeled 'not for sale to the second tier.' It means each passing season no longer carries the possibility of a miracle. And if football no longer holds the possibility of a miracle, what remains but 90 minutes of commerce?

The Counter-Intuitive Angle: a fear no one names

Now I want to flip the story, as I always do in the booth. Because if we see Mexico only as a lawsuit for justice, we miss a far more uncomfortable truth: the big-club owners are not fools, and they are not quite villains either. They are afraid.

Afraid of what? Afraid that in a football market increasingly dominated by huge money from Europe and the Middle East, a Mexican club dropping to the second tier may never return. Afraid that the thin margins of domestic football will be crushed by one bad season. Afraid that with no insurance mechanism, investors will withdraw, stars will leave, and the league will wither in a spiral no one wants to face.

That fear is real. And any honest analysis must acknowledge it. But precisely because it is real, the Mexican case is worth it: it forces that fear to be spoken rather than hidden behind glossy words about 'strategic vision' and 'sustainable development.' When a federation says it abolished promotion to protect 'the future of football,' and a judge asks back 'whose future,' the real debate begins.

The second counter-intuitive point: many fans think winning the case means promotion returns. Not quite. The September 24 hearing only addresses precautionary measures, a temporary solution to preserve the status quo while the case proceeds. November 3 addresses the constitutional merits, the core question. And even after a ruling, it can be appealed, dragging across seasons. The law firm itself said clearly that opening hearings does not mean the matter is resolved. This is what I respect about them: they promise no miracle, only a process.

The third counter-intuitive point, and perhaps the clearest to me after more than half a century: lawsuits like this often do not win in court, they win in public consciousness. Even if the case fails, it has done something decades of internal debate could not — it forces a closed-league model to explain itself to the public. And when a model must explain itself, it starts to weaken. Not because of the court, but because of the light.

I remember once in a European commentary booth, when the league I was covering changed its format to protect big clubs from relegation risk. When I asked an official why, he answered with a phrase about 'the stability of commercial value.' I wrote it in my notebook. Years later, when fans protested fiercely and the league had to partially concede, I reopened the notebook and read that line. It was still there in ink, but it was no longer true. Because the public had looked at it and said: we do not agree.

In Mexico this time, I see something similar forming, but through the legal path rather than the street. And I want to add something few mention: the law firm's call for fans to act in an informed, respectful, peaceful manner is a sharp strategy. They know that if the struggle turns violent, it loses legitimacy before the court. If it maintains the image of a movement grounded in reason and law, it exerts far more pressure than any demonstration.

That is what I call strategic dignity. In a world where every struggle can be bought off or extinguished with money, choosing to keep one's dignity is not naivety. It is a weapon.

A Closing Thought: a question to carry into the night

Now, in this small room in Kuala Lumpur, I ask myself something many Mexican fans may also be asking: can a court give back to football what its own administrators took away?

I do not know the answer. But I know that such a question, raised publicly, on a specific date — November 3 — is already a small victory. Because for decades, that question was asked only in corridors where no one was listening.

The grass never grows old; only we fade with the seasons. I am 69, and I have seen too many rule changes serving a few. But this time, in Mexico, another group decided that the rules can also be changed for justice. They promise no victory. They only promise to go to the end of the road.

And in football, sometimes one person daring to go to the end of the road is enough to shake an entire system. I will follow September 24. I will follow November 3. Not as a commentator seeking a result, but as an old man seeking an answer to the question he has carried for 53 years: whose is this sport — those who sell it, or those who believe in it?

Perhaps I will not live to see the final answer. But I will live to see November 3. And perhaps that alone is enough for me to tell myself that those nights alone in the booth, weeping over a match, were not wasted.

September 24 and November 3: When Mexican Football Takes 'Sporting Merit' to a Constitutional Court

Milestones to Watch

  • September 24: hearing on precautionary measures in the amparo against the Mexican Football Federation and Liga MX over abolishing promotion and relegation.
  • November 3: constitutional merits hearing; the core question is whether governing bodies may erase mérito deportivo.
  • The respondents must file an informe justificado — a report justifying the challenged provision.
  • The law firm Del Real & Asociados is pursuing the case; it stresses the matter is unresolved and urges fans to act peacefully and in an informed way.
  • The only current source is the law firm's own statement; cross-checking against federal court records and an official FMF response is needed.

Glossary

Amparo is a constitutional remedy unique to Mexico, letting individuals or organizations challenge acts or provisions alleged to violate constitutional rights. Medidas cautelares are interim precautionary measures to preserve the status quo while the case proceeds. Informe justificado is the mandatory report a respondent authority must file to justify the challenged act. Mérito deportivo — sporting merit — is the principle that on-pitch performance determines promotion and relegation. Liga MX is Mexico's top division; Liga de Expansión MX is the second tier directly affected by the suspension of promotion and relegation.

Source and Timeliness Note

Available information comes mainly from a single, directly interested source — the law firm Del Real & Asociados. Its statements about its own procedural filings are relatively reliable for its own facts but should be treated as advocacy. There is no independent verification from court records or an official response from the Mexican Football Federation. The story's timeliness is tied to two dates, September 24 and November 3; after these, the information will need updating. The above analysis is for sports reference only, not legal or investment advice. Legal outcomes are inherently uncertain.

Cầu thủ liên quan